The whenua may well be the winner on the day when it comes to the Ngaio Marsh Awards this year. Setting is a strong feature in the books of many of this year's finalists: from the bush and coasts of Aotearoa to the wilds of Ayrshire, the land hides secrets and lends itself to deadly situations.
Who will win Best Novel? Who will win Best First Novel? And who is on the shortlist for the Ngaio Marsh Award for Younger Readers? Judge for yourself from this list, representative of the calibre of Kiwi Crime, Thriller and Mystery writing.
Lucky Thing by Tom Baragwanath
Reading Lucky Thing has put the first book of the series, Paper Cage, on my list, not least to find out how lead character Lorraine Henry sustained that injury.
The character of Lorraine is made real with flaws and a gift for reading people. She's not a cop, but with a police force running on empty in her small Masterton town, her skills in legal record-keeping transfer to help solve the case of a girl found dumped in the bush. Baragwanath has a talent for imagery and creates a narrative which divides a community with evidence pointing at several possible perps. Paper Cage won the Michael Gifkins prize for unpublished manuscript.
Carved in Blood by Michael Bennett
Carved in Blood revisits the lives of beloved characters Hana and Addison Westerman and expands the cast to include Dax and Hana's love interest Sebastian in a story that strikes home. Ex-husband, father, and policeman Jaye has been shot while intervening in a liquor store burglary. Is the crime what it appears to be on the surface? Or is it a setup as an unidentified caller to Addison's help line claims?
It's good to dip into the adventures of this crew again, moving to share their pain and bear witness to institutional racism under the banner of the justice system in Aotearoa. Bennett is known for his mahi highlighting racial injustices and shares his knowledge of both police procedure and te ao Māori in this internationally acclaimed third book of the series.
Softly Calls The Devil by Chris Blake
Winner of the 2026 NZ Booklovers Award, Softly Calls The Devil is quite blokey - centred on male characters and told with a fair bit of banter. The plot, however, is deadly serious and action-packed from the get-go.
The story builds interest with hidden pasts on both sides of the uniform and keeps pulling the rug out from the readers' guesswork with shock events that change the focus of Matt Buchanan's investigation. The scene-setting in this book is so top-notch I feel like I'm still in the car driving up and down the West Coast: through Haast and Hawea, to Queenstown and the Lakes. Adding to the feeling of dread building in this gripping thriller, Blake gives the reader not only an impression of the wilderness of the area but also how huge the West Coast really is.
The Good Father by Liam McIlvanney
Liam McIlvanney is a big-hitter in the mystery writing world. The Good Father was nominated for the Ian Fleming Steel Dagger at the Dagger Awards this year and it lived up to my high expectations.
The Good Father is a moving and horrifying psychological thriller told in the vein of Scots Gothic, brought to life with beautifully curated imagery of the wild, ancient land masses and seascapes of Ayrshire and Arran. Readers witness the impact of the abduction on the idyllic middle-class existence of the family, particularly the anti-hero of Gordon Rutherford. With a subtle theme of being underwater throughout, McIlvanney doesn't so much examine the effect on the family as drop in a pebble and watch the reverberations spread throughout the community.
When the Deep, Dark Bush Swallows You Whole by Geoff Parkes
When the Deep, Dark Bush Swallows You Whole
Geoff Parkes does some great scene setting with a story of small-town Aotearoa squirming with eccentric characters. Those in Nashville, a farming locality in the King Country, are far from endearing and very suspicious: at best voyeurs, at worst, violent and crazy. There are more suspects in the first couple of chapters than you can shake a stick at.
Emilia Sovernen comes from Finland determined to find answers in her sister Sanna's disappearance a year ago: the trail gone cold, the case never solved. She debunks the theory of a serial killer in an instant. How to narrow the suspects down, in a town where the cops turn a blind eye and everyone has each other's back, pointing at a 'mysterious serial killer' to save the rep of their town? Parkes impresses with his first crime novel, which went viral in crime-reading and writing circles last year.
Hooked Up by Fiona Sussman
Named one of The Listener's Best 100 Books (2025), Auckland Libraries top 100 Books (2025/6) and one of the Top Beach Reads (2025/6), the second unputdownable story in the Bandara/Stark series features an indomitable, unconventional police team fighting crime in a tiny kiwi beach town. It's a case of small town, big crime - a homicide being just the tip of the iceberg.
Referencing Agatha Christie, Hooked Up remains true to form with characters who demonstrate method and psychological motivation, skilful imagery, an astounding setup (a reality TV dating show that leads to murder) and a plot that keeps the reader guessing until the last minute.
A Beautiful Family by Jennifer Trevelyan
A Beautiful Family has also been highlighted by the book industry as of high-quality writing. It was shortlisted for the NZ Booklovers Awards, longlisted for the John Creasey New Blood Dagger and its author Jennifer Trevelyan was selected as one of the 2026 New Voices of Aotearoa.
This tension-filled story is a gripping read. It reminded me of Ian Cross's The God Boy - the narrator is a ten-year-old. The familial relationships are brilliantly done and realistic: Trevelyan's characters gradually come into focus, becoming sharp and leaving the reader wondering who is in danger. The author holds back with a remarkable sense of control, driving the reader crazy with little drips of the mystery, building tension and the most unease I've felt in a long time.
It's been well worth the wait with life struggles holding up the works for Ngaio Marsh Judges this year. Watch this space for the winners!
More
- Ngaio Marsh Award for Best Crime Novel
- Ngaio Marsh Award for Best First Novel
- Ngaio Marsh Award for Younger Readers
- Looking for something to read? Try our mystery fiction reading guide
- Ask our Readers Advisory team for a customised Reading Recommendation

Add a comment to: The 2026 Ngaio Marsh Awards for Best Crime Novel from Aotearoa